I bought an old (1994) sealed Ravensburger puzzle off eBay of the Titanic sinking and it came with a mock newspaper article. It is the size and feel of an old newspaper. :
Titanic, a traditional puzzle - Stave Puzzles
Ravensburger 1500 The New York Times 16.4.1912: Titanic sinks : r/Jigsawpuzzles
Titanic - White Star line 1000 Piece Puzzle
Titanic Now Boarding Kevin Walsh 1000 Pc Jigsaw Puzzle - Etsy
New York Times TITANIC Collector Series 1000pc Puzzle With Poster Unopened Bag | eBay
Ravensburger 1500 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle - Titanic Sinks - New York Times Cover | #3243236119
New York Times Titanic 1912 U.S. Mint Coin Collection Framed - 4 Coins - Actual Authentic Collectable | Museum Mint, Historic Numismatics, Coin Collecting
I Survived the Sinking of the Titanic, 1912 (I Survived Series #1) by Lauren Tarshis, Paperback | Barnes & Noble®
Amazon.com: SUNSOUT INC - The Titanic - 1000 pc Large Pieces Jigsaw Puzzle by Artist: Keith Walsh - Finished Size 27" x 35" - MPN# 13830 : Toys & Games
Amazon.com: Trefl Red 1000 Piece Puzzle - Titanic : Toys & Games
Titanic - White Star line 1000 Piece Puzzle
Selten? Ravensburger Puzzle New York Times: TITANIC SINKS 1500 Stck. mit Faksimile Sehr guter Zustand | eBay
New York Times TITANIC Collector Series 1000pc Puzzle With Poster Unopened Bag | eBay
Vintage 1967 New York Times Titanic Puzzle 500 Piece Parker Brothers | eBay
Titanic: White Star Line - 1000pc Jigsaw Puzzle by Masterpieces - SeriousPuzzles.com
New York Times Front Page Puzzle – The New York Times Store
Amazon.com: New York Puzzle Company - Penguin Random House Titanic First Accounts - 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle : Toys & Games
RARE? RAVENSBURGER PUZZLE New York Times: TITANIC SINKS 1500 pc w Facsimile VGC £14.99 - PicClick UK
Day & Night NYC Skyline, a 1500-piece Puzzle by Ravensburger - Walmart.com
Titanic, 1000 Pieces, Piatnik | Puzzle Warehouse
Titanic 3D Jigsaw Puzzle: 440 Pcs | AreYouGame – AreYouGame.com